Who says what are games, what are game-elements, gamemechanics and gameplay

04/10/2011 16:41

Wittgenstein (1953, 1958); “admitted failure in defining the essential characteristics of games, noting that there are no properties that are common to all games and that games belong in the same semantic category only because they bear a “family resemblance” to one another.

Bernard Suits (1987) “Definition of playing a game; the voluntary effort to overcome unnecessary obstacles

Brian Sutton-Smith: “each person defines games in his own way- the antropologist and folklorists in terms of historical origin; the military men, businessmen and educators in terms of usages; the social scientists in term of psychological and social functions. There is overwhelming evidence in all this that the meaning of games is, in part, a function of the idea of those who think of them”


In an attempt to find the game-elements listed and defined I searched and made a matrix, whereby I took several liberty on the definitions in the ambition to make it less broad and wide, but while doing so I discovered it more and more to be like a bowl of fruit, apples are hard to compare with a banana, but still they match together in this bowl.

How do the following people define a game?
Johan Huizinga, Caillois, Costello and Edmonds, Crookall, Oxford, and Saunders, Katie Salen and Erik Zimmerman, R. Garris, Dr Martin Seligman, Amy Jo Kim, Brian Sutton-Smith, Burghardt, Pamela Kato, Malone and Lepper, Hannu Korhonen, Ritterfeld, Cody and Vorderer, Csikszentmihalyi, Nick Yee, Gabe Zicherman, Cordova and Lepper, Sherry, Raph Koster, Jane Mc Gonigal, Barbaros Bostan, Tom Chatfield, Chris Crawford.

Check the interactive table with quotes and definitions on all bullit’s and numbers:

Reoccurrence (amount) of specific game-elements:

Game-elements categorized in gameplay and gamemechanics

Gameplay (these elements are located more at the player’s side):

  • Engagement
  • Challenge
  • Social binding
  • Mystery
  • Freedom
  • Identity

Gamemechanics (these elements are located more at the game’s side):

  • Goals/rewards
  • Control
  • Interaction
  • Rules
  • Unreal
  • Competition
  • Chance
  • Unproductive
  • Sensory stimuli

Categories

Alice, apply play, data-visualisation, design thinking, english, favorite, game, play, psychology, R&D, serious

Care to comment?

2 responses to 'Who says what are games, what are game-elements, gamemechanics and gameplay'

  • ellis wrote a comment on 4-17-2012

    mmmmh, just found this link: http://www.jesperjuul.net/text/gameplayerworld/

    Jesper Jull doing the exact same…

  • ellis wrote a comment on 8-8-2013

    Mark Overmars: A computergame is a software program in which one or more players make decissions through the control of game objects and resources, in pursuit of a goal.